New Location and Menu!

Check out our new location and all of our fun additions to our menu! Our gift shop has local items, gift baskets, balloons, ice cream, cookies, fudge, mustards, hot sauce, soft pretzels,  pretzel dogs, and a variety of subs, wraps, and lunch specials! Call ahead for pick up or delivery.

FREE Delivery for Key West and the lower Keys!

Join our Facebook group Sweetest Knights Meals To-Go for details about our weekly pre-ordered dinner specials!

Ask about catered lunches and our new fundraising program!

2510 N Roosevelt Blvd

Key West, FL 33040



Variety Gift Boxes

We have delicious flavor combinations in our variety gift boxes that make the perfect gift. The small gift box includes Chocolate, Caramel Chocolate Sea Salt, and Chocolate Peanut Butter (approximately 1/2 lb). The large gift box includes Chocolate, Caramel Chocolate Sea Salt, Vanilla, & Cookies N Cream (approximately 1 lb).

Buy Fudge

Giving Back

A portion of all proceeds from sales of fudge go to our partners, causes and charities that have teamed up with us to raise funds.

The Sweetest Thing in Paradise

In 2009, Kim and Chad Knight put their ideas and entrepreneurial spirits to work with the origination of a small, family-owned, homemade fudge business…
Read More